The Hollywood version of an image can become so immensely pervasive that, at times, it can be almost impossible to picture anything else in your mind. The Lord of the Rings/Hobbit franchise is one such example. Trying to imagine middle earth with different geography, heroes with different faces, villains with different armour, can strain at your imagination. That is why it's important that at times you need to take part in a little visual palette cleansing. Inspired by a twitter post that's exactly what i've done here. I've gone on little visual journey through different illustrators interpretations of hoe Tolkiens worlds look. I'm not going to blether about them much. I just hope you find stuff that you've not seen before and that you like.
|
Sara Kipin |
This book cover reminded me of Frank Frazetta's illustration of Orcs. The kind of grinding march towards battle is a great image.
|
Frank Frazetta |
|
Angus McBride |
And you can't go wrong with a bit of Angus McBride. His illustrations for the MERP publications were all gorgeous pieces of art.
|
Angus Mcbride |
|
Cor Blok |
But sometimes it's worth diving into lesser known stuff just to give your mind a jolt.
|
Stephanie Vecellio |
|
Frank Frazetta |
|
Ingahild Grathmer (Queen Margarethe II) |
|
Tom Jung |
And you have to remember the Jackson version wasn't the first attempt at bring LOTR to the screen. This poster image from an uncredited Tom Jung is classic.
|
Eric Fraser |
At the same time there is something to be said for the classic black and white illustration that apes the look of the woodcut. An attempt to show what illustrations from versions of the tale may have looked like if the were published in middle earth perhaps.
|
M. Belomlinskij |
|
Frank Frazetta |
|
Jian Guo |
And we have to remember that LOTR is international, seeing how different cultures represent the tale in their own way is always enlightening from a design point of view.
|
M. Belomlinskij |
|
Ted Naismith |
|
Sergey Yuhimov |
Using medieval paintings as an influence for art work shows is perfect for the near mythical tales.
|
Sergey Yuhimov |
|
Livia Rusz
|
And it shouldn't be forgotten that these are books for children.
|
Ian Miller |
|
Ian Miller |
A familiar artist takes on a familiar story but produces something you couldn't forsee.
|
JRR Tolkein |
But it must always be remembered that the author had his own vision of his own world.
Thank you for the recap, I love it. Some of them are really beautiful, and all of them are inspirational. You are totally right, it's refreshing to see other views different from the movies.
ReplyDeleteFantastic look a different interpretations of Tolkien. I'm really like those medieval ones
ReplyDeleteGreat round up! There's so much LotR artwork out there it's fantastic. Even the great John Howe said after the movies it's hard not to draw Frodo like Elijah Wood. The classics of Johne Howe, Alan Lee and Ian Miller are my favorite LotR artists. Ted Naismith and Angus McBride are also really good.
ReplyDeleteDon't forget even John Blanche did some LotR work! https://www.johnblancheprints.com/shop/battle-of-five-armies/
I've actually gotten into the Lord of the Rings/Hobbit Strategy Battle Game this past year. While I wish the license wasn't entirely based on the films, the actual game is really, really good and the range has some great models in it.
Some great and classic pics there. Nice. Thanks for posting.
ReplyDeleteThanks for this. I could use a reminder that there is always more than one way to see things.
ReplyDeleteAh!! Great pics!
ReplyDeleteRyder Strickland and I have wondered about the plausibility of Frank Frazetta's depiction of Eowyn and the Witch King. While not quite a chainmail bikini, her armour would make her disguise a bit unconvincing.
ReplyDeleteFabulous selection.
ReplyDeleteI can't tell you how much I enjoyed this palate cleaner. You are absolutely right that it's important to dislodge the dominant Hollywood aesthetic every once in a while, especially when it comes to something as expansive as the LOTR.
ReplyDeleteFor my part, nothing beats the woodcuts like those of Fraser or Grathemer.
One question: did you give any consideration to including the Brothers Hildebrandt?
The Jian Guo image is stunning. Will have to look more into that
ReplyDeleteMakes me wonder whether Frank Frazetta's art was an inspiration for the original LotR ranges by GW back in the 80's; like the Witch King - http://collecting-citadel-miniatures.com/wiki/index.php/File:BME2_Nazgul_on_foot.jpg
ReplyDeleteYou missed an important entry, The Hobbit illustrated by Tove Jansson. Amazingly different take on middle earth and with a more personal touch and much more love.
ReplyDelete